Everyone wants this elephant.

This holiday, we’re redefining what it means to be a white elephant—because this gift is neither useless or unwanted. Quite the opposite, actually. No one will want to let it go! Each collection includes five signature Jeni’s flavors (chosen by us and we’re not telling what they are, so don’t ask!). It’s also the only way to get your hands on a Jeni’s pint koozie, specially designed by the Jeni’s Art + Design Team to keep your mitts toasty while enjoying ice cream straight from the pint. So go ahead, put a little mystery into your gift giving this year.